CPU's rarely go bad, I doubt that's the issue unless you didn't attach the heatsink right.
Even if you didn't attach the heatsink right, I still doubt that's what the burning smell would be seeming how all the intel CPU's have a safety feature with heat. If it goes over 100c it shuts down automatically.
I wouldn't send the CPU back until you're 100% certain that CPU is fried. Thus, pull all the components out of the PC and check them like stated. Then re-seat EVERYTHING